Category Archives: We Are Not Alone

Part of the problem

This reporting below is symptomatic of a larger issue that we have been unsuccessful at conveying to our state legislators so far, the need for fundamental school finance reform. It’s not a question of taking money from one school and giving it to another. It’s about funding all our schools adequately. This issue really comes down to a question of our future priorities as a society. The quicker we get the dialogue shifted to a new level of discourse, the quicker we will see real and sustainable reform.

A legislative resolution calling for school funding reform by July 2009 is purely politics and won’t get to a vote in the Assembly, a North Woods legislator said Friday.

State Rep. Dan Meyer (R-Eagle River) said school funding reform is such a difficult issue that little progress will be made until the governor’s office makes it a priority.

“The problem is that we’ve got 99 Assembly people who are all representing different school districts,” said Meyer. “I’d support it if my district got more money, but then we’d be taking from someone else. Do you think Milwaukee will jump up and down and support it? Not if they are going to lose money.”

The statements came in response to Assembly Joint Resolution 35 and Senate Joint Resolution 27, which call upon legislators to reform the school aid formula by July 1, 2009. They were co-authored by Sen. Roger Breske (D-Eland) and Rep. Sondy Pope-Roberts (D-Verona).

The resolutions say that the present funding system is not working, problems are aggravated by declining enrollment, more and more referenda are being held to exceed revenue limits, and it is the job of the Legislature to change it.

Meyer, who sits on the powerful Joint Finance Committee, said budget hearings across the state have attracted teachers and school administrators who all have the same message: The formula needs to change and they need more money.

“A lot of that testimony came from educators in areas of the state where they get a lot more aid than schools in my district,” said Meyer. “The problem is, none of the schools are happy even though more than 50 cents of every state tax dollar goes to education.”

Robert Godfrey

Leave a comment

Filed under AMPS, Gimme Some Truth, Pope-Roberts/Breske Resolution, School Finance, Take Action, We Are Not Alone

We Are Not Alone #12

The City of Menasha’s Board of Education meets tonight to try and wrestle with an $800,000 budget deficit. Chief among their concerns is maintaining SAGE classrooms as the number of incoming kindergarteners increases each year.

Menasha School Board focuses on budget deficit

I applaud the Menasha Board of Education, and all the many other school districts around the state that recognize and value the benefits of smaller class sizes. In dire fiscal situations, an easy solution would be to increase class sizes, but school boards are holding the line on quality versus quantity.

Karen Bassler

Leave a comment

Filed under AMPS, Budget, We Are Not Alone

We Are Not Alone #11

Most of the “We Are Not Alone” series offers glimpses of how other districts are suffering. I’m happy today to post an entry that focuses on positive action for improvement in New Glarus. It isn’t much, but these days any signs of hope are good.

Some highlights (full story):

NEW GLARUS — A new name and a focused purpose were the results of the meeting of the Citizen’s Action Committee in New Glarus Wednesday night.

After discussion that covered a variety of topics related to the failed school referendums, the committee set a short-term goal as one step on the path toward its long-term goal: a strong future for New Glarus schools.

To that end, the committee has renamed itself the Concerned Citizens for a Strong School. The committee will remain a group of citizens, rather than being appointed by, and thereby connected to, the school board.

Bright also said the board is considering holding a referendum in the fall for money that will cover the operations of the schools for the 2007-08 school year.

According to John Johnson, director of educational informational services for the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction, state statutes allow districts to pass a referendum to exceed revenue caps by Nov. 6 and still have them apply to the current school year.

Bright said the school board made a policy change at its last meeting which will allow the public to more easily voice its opinion at board meetings.

“They (the school board) are going to discuss ways to make themselves more accessible to the community so people have the opportunity to (be heard),” he said.

Thomas J. Mertz

Leave a comment

Filed under AMPS, Local News, Referenda, School Finance, Take Action, We Are Not Alone

We Are Not Alone #10

The referendum in Horicon failed by a vote of 873 to 683. Now they face the familiar choices:

“We are going to have to make a determination if we are going to fund the program or cut programs,” David Westimayer said.

They are also looking to continue leveraging municipal finances. As Madison moves in this direction, we may face similar problems:

The district-wide recreation program with the YMCA of Dodge County will be on the agenda of the May 21 board meeting.

“It is the same contract at the same cost,” McCartney said, noting that money previously received from the city has dried up.

He noted that city sponsorship would benefit only Horicon residents, while the district funding the program benefits everyone living within the district.

Thomas J. Mertz

Leave a comment

Filed under AMPS, Elections, Local News, Referenda, School Finance, We Are Not Alone

Quote of the Day

“There is no fat in our budget. Educational liposuction is no longer an option in Glidden. The option now is educational amputations.”

Mark Luoma, superintendent, principal and technology director within the Glidden School District

Full story on Joint Finance hearing here and also on our new and under construction and design (re)consideration Press Room page (thanks reader, Karen Bassler).

Thomas J. Mertz

Leave a comment

Filed under AMPS, Quote of the Day, School Finance, We Are Not Alone

We are not alone #9

A spiral of cuts coming to the Waukesha School District.

According to gmtoday, to address the budget deficit in the Waukesha School District, calls have come for “the proposed elimination of elementary, middle and high school athletics, clubs and other co-curricular activities for a combined savings of $1.2 million.”

And, that’s only about one-third of the total cuts needed of $3.7 million. The tentative list is to fill gaps in the 2007-08 budget and is being presented now to give community members as much time as possible to respond.

District administrator Dave Schmidt said, “The list I have presented is really a list of bad choices, but given the current reality of the deficit we face and state laws that limit us, we’re left with few options of where to cut.”

Robert Godfrey

Leave a comment

Filed under AMPS, Local News, School Finance, We Are Not Alone

We are not alone #8

Eau Claire makes some painful decisions.

“Little Red School parents and staff exchanged hugs and condolences Monday night after the Eau Claire school board voted 5-to-2 to close the school. But the cost-cutting measure, one of more than $5 million cuts approved at the meeting, didn’t surprise school supporters.

‘Honestly, it doesn’t come as a shock,’ said Barb Habben, a second grade teacher.

Parents and students had prepared for the worst, said Little Red parent teacher association president Kathy Buyze. After the vote several audience members left the auditorium.
……
‘There’s a lot of frustration, and a lot of unanswered questions,’ she said.

Board members said they regretted closing the school, but needed to make the cut to help balance the budget. .

‘There’s not a person up here that wants to make these cuts,’ board President Carol Olson told a crowd of more than 1,000 inside the Memorial High School auditorium. ‘We wanted a successful referendum, so we wouldn’t have to do some of these things … But we have to move forward and allow our district to make some decisions.’ In all, the group eliminated a little more than $5 million from its 2007-08 budget.
………..
During an 80 minute public comment session before the meeting, more than 40 students, parents, teachers and community members expressed their opinions about the district’s budget. The speakers addressed a wide array of topics, ranging from the importance of language courses to the value of administration positions.

When the board later moved ahead with budget reductions, audience members routinely booed the comments of members who advocated cuts. After a failed motion to disregard the district-developed list of budget reduction, several attendees walked out of the meeting. More audience members left after the board voted 5-to-2 to close Little Red School, which will save $586,000 annually.”

Robert Godfrey

Leave a comment

Filed under AMPS, Local News, School Finance, We Are Not Alone

It Could Be Worse

There has been some tension between MMSD Board members and administrators, but generally the relationships have been civil and those involved have displayed mutual respect. All involved should be proud of this.

The situation in the Menomonie Area district appears to be pretty bad. (More here and here.)

Besides limiting contact between board members and administrators, the March 30 letter tells school board members that administrators have been instructed to notify Harness if a school board member contacts them by phone, e-mail or in person.

In addition, the letter requires administrators to request permission from Harness before contacting a school board member; they must also provide a reason for doing so.

According to the memo, Harness must be present during any meetings between administrators and school board members and that the meetings must be prearranged.

The letter, signed by the administrators in the district, indicated that they felt their trust had been violated when an alternate staffing plan was introduced at a March 19 school board meeting. The plan was aimed at saving programs and positions in an effort to forestall the need for a referendum at this time.

I don’t think you can blame this entirely on the state finance system, but clearly the pressures of annual budget conflicts and the difficulties of referenda are part of it.

Thomas J. Mertz

Leave a comment

Filed under AMPS, Budget, Referenda, School Finance, We Are Not Alone

Saving Schools and More

A group of parents and community members has begun organizing to agitate for an operating referendum to be placed on the ballot February 19th 2008 (the Spring Primary, including presidential). The details of the referendum are still in the early planning stages. I am part of this group.

As they consider the 2007-2008 budget (including school closings), it is important to show the Board of Education that there is broad and growing support for this referendum. With the realistic possibility of a successful referendum prior to the next budget cycle the Board can be induced to take nearly irreversible cuts (such as closing schools or eliminating 5th Grade Strings) off the table for this year.

You can help with this. There is a letter that will be submitted to the Board on April 19th here. If you support this, please say so and add your name and information in the comments. There are also some talking points here. We are asking that as many people as possible attend the upcoming Board meetings (April 17th and April 19th in particular) and express support for a referendum and not cutting those things that will be difficult to restore. We are also asking that individuals and groups contact the Board and news outlets (Capital Times: tctvoice@madison.com; Wisconsin State Journal: wsjopine@madison.com) to express support.

As always, educating and agitating on the state finance system that has created these conditions is important.

Thank you

Thomas J. Mertz

26 Comments

Filed under AMPS, Budget, Elections, Local News, Referenda, School Finance, Take Action, We Are Not Alone

School Funding Reform Press Conference April 19 at 10 a.m. in Assembly Parlor

Here’s the press release from WAES…Hope many AMPS members can attend this important event….

WAES and other school-funding reform advocates will be gathering at the State Capitol in Madison on Thursday, April 19, to support Senate Joint Resolution 27 and Assembly Joint Resolution 35 asking the Legislature to change Wisconsin’s school-funding system.

We need you to attend, if possible, and support these important resolutions. A press conference will begin at 10 a.m. in the Assembly Parlor. This would also be an excellent opportunity to set up meetings with your legislators or their aides and talk about school funding, the joint resolution, and reform. If you need help, let me know. It would be a good idea to visit the WAES website at http://www.excellentschools. org to study up on the resolution and its intent before you go .

If you plan to attend, please let Tom Beebe know using the contact info below so that all groups and organizations in attendance are recognized. Resolution sponsors Rep. Sondy Pope-Roberts and Sen. Roger Breske are hosting the press conference.


Thomas S. Beebe
Institute for Wisconsin’s Future
1717 South 12thStreet
Milwaukee, WI 53204

Voice: 414-384-9094
Fax:414-384- 9098
Cell: 920-650-0525
E-mail:tbeebe@ wisconsinsfuture .org

http://www.excellentschools. org
http://www.wisconsinsfuture. org

Leave a comment

Filed under AMPS, Pope-Roberts/Breske Resolution, School Finance, Take Action, We Are Not Alone