The Wrong Frame, The Frame of the (Center) Right

brooks-dunce

There is a lot of buzz on David Brook’s latest column and its topic — Obama’s pick for Secretary of Education and the direction of education policy in his administration (weigh in on the latter here).  Many of the buzzers, like Brooks, simplemindedly frame the choice as between choosing a “reformer” and choosing a stalwart defender of the status quo (in Brooks’ case  the latter is described as “teachers’ unions and the members of the Ed School establishment, who emphasize greater funding, smaller class sizes and superficial reforms”).

We’ve seen this in Madison before — the subtle “reformers as good guys,” others as uncaring, self interested or misguided defenders of a failed system.  It wasn’t accurate or useful then and it isn’t now.

Much of the current discourse is derived from what Marion Brady in 2001 identified as a the narrowing of reform to “introducing market forces” via “standards and accountability” and the definition of standards and accountability as  standardized testing and blaming teachers (and teacher unions), with a little privatization in the mix.

If it isn’t obvious to you how wrong and destructive this is, click the link and read what Brady had to say.

For myself, I’ll just hit a few very quick points.  First, market forces aren’t what they’ve cracked up to be (pun intended).  Second, the way to improve teaching is not by attacking teachers, teacher trainers and teacher unions…none of them are going away and all them are interested in improvement.  Greater funding and smaller classes are not superficial, just look at the research or ask a teacher  — oh yeah Brooks has dismissed the knowledge of researchers and teachers, pretty clever of him.  Last, this crisis mentality is throwing the baby out with the bathwater.  We have many great schools and teachers, a system that works for most and desperately needs to be improved in order to work for all.  I don’t see Brooks calling for Socialism or Communism as a fix for a financial and industrial system that is obviously broken; why call for radical changes in an education system that isn’t broken?

A couple of links:  Jim Horn’s take at Schools Matter and Bob Somerby at the Daily Howler on this column and related failings in education reporting (scroll down).

Thomas J.  Mertz

4 Comments

Filed under "education finance", Accountability, Arne Duncan, Best Practices, education, Gimme Some Truth, National News, School Finance

WAES School Funding Update, 12/1/2008

waesgraphic

    The Wisconsin Alliance for Excellent Schools (WAES) is a statewide, independent, membership-based organization of educators, school board members, students, parents, community leaders, researchers, citizens, and community activists whose lone goal is the comprehensive reform of Wisconsin’s school-funding system. If you would like more information about the organization — or on becoming part of WAES — contact Tom Beebe at 920-650-0525 or tbeebe@excellentschools.org.
    *******
    New report calls for balanced approach to solving fiscal deficit

    Most of us who fight for school-funding reform now understand that underfunded schools are just one symptom of a crisis in public structures. To save those services that level the playing field for all of us, we will need a balanced approach to government that includes new revenues as well as prioritization of spending and cuts in non-essential services.

    To answer the constant drumbeat calling for smaller government and no tax increases, a new report details “an inventory of options for reforming the state’s tax system and finding a balanced approach for filling the deficit.” “Catalog of Tax Reform Options” (http://www.wisconsinsfuture.org/publications/taxes/1108WI_TaxReformOptions.pdf) was authored by the Wisconsin Council of Children and Families (http://www.wccf.org/) and the Institute for Wisconsin’s Future (IWF at http://www.wisconsinsfuture.org).

    IWF’s Jack Norman, along with the report’s other authors, talked about the report in the Nov. 22 edition of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel in an opinion piece entitled “How to raise money for our state (http://www.jsonline.com/news/opinion/34903414.html).” Norman was also Ben Merens’ guest, Nov. 24, on “At Issue” (http://www.wpr.org/merens/index.cfm?strDirection=Prev&dteShowDate=2008-11-24%2017%3A00%3A00) on Wisconsin Public Radio.
    *******
    Budget cuts could degrade Rhinelander High School

    Rhinelander Board of Education meetings are very well attended these days as the community discusses the future of their children’s education in light of a failed Nov. 4 referendum. Recent discussions are centering on moving back to a seven-period day at the high-school and put the hockey and swimming teams on the budget chopping block in light of the need to trim about $2 million from the district’s 2009-10 budget.

    Rhinelander implemented a four-period day 10 years ago because it was good for kids. High school Principal Terry Fondow told the board recently, however, that “because of the district’s fiscal reality” he was proposing moving back to a seven period day. This would mean reducing the number of graduation credits and advanced placement courses, increasing the student-teacher ratio, and eliminating staff. Fondow said, “It’s no doubt that I’m proposing a degradation of the high school, both in breadth and depth (http://www.newsofthenorth.net/article.cfm?articleID=24365).”

    Board President Chuck Fitzgerald told the audience at a recent meeting that the group would be considering budget cuts into April or May, but that athletic programs will be among them (http://www.newsofthenorth.net/article.cfm?articleID=24390). He explained that one proposal is to close the swimming pool which would mean the elimination of the hockey and swimming programs, both of which use the pool.

    Proposing the cuts, administrators said they worry they will damage education. “We are now at the level of cutting severely into what is good for children,” said co-assistant superintendent Carole Witt Starck.
    *******
    Proposed cuts in Merrill could “damage education”

    Options is the key word in the Merrill School District as the community looks to make $750,000 in for the 2009-10 school year (http://www.wausaudailyherald.com/article/20081202/WDH0101/812020464/1981). This discussion also follows on the heels of an unsuccessful referendum to exceed revenue limits ($2.9 million) on Nov. 4.

    Merrill has cut its budget each year since 2000-01, and, during that span, has cut $5 million. Recommendations include eliminating the positions of three literacy teachers, cutting two teachers in high school elective courses, eliminating a middle school band teacher (reducing lesson and instruction time), and eliminating fourth grade at Maple Grove Elementary School by splitting the students among third- and fifth-grade classes.
    *******
    Rural school finance is subject of Dec. 10 “webinar”

    Rural School and Community Trust (http://www.ruraledu.org) will be holding a webinar — a web-based seminar — on the top 10 things you can do to improve Wisconsin’s financing of rural schools. The event will be held on Wednesday, Dec. 10, at 1 p.m. and consist of a conference call and a slide presentation.

    Amanda Adler, director of the Rural Education Finance Center, will host the discussion.

    Webinars are a regular benefit to members of the Rural School Innovation Network (RSIN), but they are also open to non-members for a fee of $45. For more information on this event or joining the RSIN, go to http://www.ruraledu.org/site/c.beJMIZOCIrH/b.3937703/k.5F87/RSIN_News_and_Updates.htm.
    *******
    Waupun hopes third time a charm for referendum

    In an effort to keep two schools open, the administration of the Waupun School District recently came forward with a $3 million “high-stakes referendum” for the April ballot (http://www.fdlreporter.com/article/20081203/FON0101/812030440/0/FON0201).

    In the past two years, voters have rejected two operational referenda. The decision to try again was among seven options outlined to balance the 2009-10 budget and beyond. One Waupun resident said “we have to make it clear (to voters) what will happen if this referendum fails. If people realize these schools will close or their child has to ride the bus over an hour every day, they might vote a little differently.”

    Closing the two schools would save over $400,000. Other options for reducing the budget include cutting additional personnel, a wage freeze for non-represented employees, eliminating four athletic teams, cutting middle school extra-curricular activities, and abolishing the police liaison position.
    *******
    Membership in WAES is more important now than ever

    Two organizations and three individuals are the latest welcomed additions to WAES, a diverse, statewide coalition working for school-funding reform. Joining are Glorie Salas, Ken and Kim Bates, the Neshkoro School Visioning Committee (in the Westfield School District http://www.westfield.k12.wi.us/), and Price County Citizens Who CARE, the group that “started” the school-funding reform movement in Wisconsin when members walked from Butternut to Madison about 10 years ago to “talk about” their problems with the present finance system.

    If you haven’t joined the effort to bring the reform message to everyone, do it now. WAES is an independent, non-profit, dues-supported organization. If we are going to organize communities around the state for change, we need your talent, your time, and your financial support. Go to http://www.excellentschools.org/about/join.htm … it’s quick, it’s easy, and you can join online.

    When you pay your dues, you are helping to finance the core educational mission of WAES. Numbering 120 strong organizations and individuals, our mission is to make sure that as many people as possible get the message of reform. We do that by traveling around the state and holding school-funding change discussions in church basements, schools, kitchens, and meeting halls. You can find out how to bring this message to your community at http://www.excellentschools.org/calendar/SchoolFundingWorkshop.htm.

    Thomas J. Mertz

    Leave a comment

    Filed under "education finance", Best Practices, Budget, education, finance, Local News, Referenda, referendum, School Finance, Take Action

    Education Tweak, Winter 2009

    edtweak

    Click on image for pdf

    Enjoy.

    Thomas J. Mertz

    Leave a comment

    Filed under "education finance", Best Practices, Contracts, education, finance, Gimme Some Truth, National News, nclb, No Child Left Behind, School Finance

    Quote of the Day — The Bailout We Need

    school_funding

    Our preoccupation with the immediate crisis of financial capital is causing us to overlook the bigger crisis in America’s human capital. While we commit hundreds of billions of taxpayer dollars to Wall Street, we’re slashing our outlays for public education….

    The result, across the nation: Teachers are being laid off and new hiring frozen, after-school programs cut, so called “noncritical” subjects like history eliminated, schools closed, and tuitions hiked at state colleges and universities.

    It’s absurd. We¹re bailing out every major bank to get financial capital flowing again. But we¹re squeezing the main sources of our nation’s human capital. Yet America’s future competitiveness and the standard of living of our people depend largely our peoples’ skills, and our capacities to communicate and solve problems and innovate ­ not on our ability to borrow money.

    Robert Reich, “Of Financial Capital and Human Capital: Why We’re Bailing Out Wall Street While Allowing Our Schools to Get Clobbered.”

    Thomas J. Mertz

    Leave a comment

    Filed under "education finance", Budget, education, finance, National News, School Finance

    Building on Victory – Next for CAST

    logo

    Join with CAST to raise school finance reform to top of the agenda!

    The referendum passed – thanks to all for your support and hard work! Now it’s time to turn our energy to school finance reform!

    Without changes in the way Wisconsin finances schools, Madison and other districts will face a future of continued budget cuts and divisive referendum battles. Our local state legislators supported the referendum and support fair funding for schools. We need them to put school finance reform on the top of their agenda for the next state budget.

    Please join CAST on Wednesday, Dec. 3rd 6:30pm at Hawthorne Library and help plan an event at the State Capitol in early January to meet our legislators and ask for their leadership.

    Let’s plan a creative and constructive action that involves everybody– kids, parents, educators, grandparents. Bring your ideas!

    Hawthorne Library is located at 2707 E. Washington Ave., 246-4548, See for this link for directions.

    If you have questions or cannot join us on Dec. 3rd, but have an idea or want to be part of the event in January, please contact Jill Jacklitz at madisoncast@sbcglobal.net

    Community and Schools Together

    Thomas J. Mertz

    Leave a comment

    Filed under "education finance", Best Practices, Budget, education, finance, Local News, School Finance, Take Action

    No need to know? (updated)

    blank-pages

    Update: The strategic planning proposal has been posted here (thanks Barb).  No time to go into depth right now, except to say that it appears to follow what was done in Green Bay fairly closely, even recommending the same facilitator (Supt. Keith Marty of Menomonee Falls).

    On the agenda for the Monday, December 1, 2008 MMSD Board of Education Meeting is an action item asking for approval of a proposed “structure and timeline for the MMSD strategic planning process,” and authorization for the “the Superintendent to pursue the key steps for implementation.”  This could be a big deal, I don’t know.  Short of contacting Board members or administrators or staff, there is no way to know.

    There is public comment at the meeting Monday.  However, any comment on this proposal would be rushed because the proposal is not posted on the web and at best the public may be able to get a copy some time Monday.

    I would guess the Board has seen and commented on versions of the proposal, but it has not been on an official agenda, nor has it been discussed at a public meeting.

    This is no way to begin strategic planning that is supposed to include the larger community.  How can we be included if we don’t even know what is going on?

    In messages to the community, Board President Arlene Silveira has promised that the strategic planning process would “include strong community input.”  Maybe that will come later.  So far there has been no effort to inform the public of anything of substance and on Monday they are scheduled to vote.

    The “structure and timeline” might not be a big deal, it might be simple housekeeping  — no way to know — but if it is important, and they are serious about involving the community, they should slow things down, share the knowledge, ask for input…and involve the public from the very start.

    Thomas J. Mertz

    2 Comments

    Filed under Accountability, Best Practices, education, Local News

    It depends on how you ask

    telephone_antique

    Johnny Thunders, “Ask me no questions” (click to listen or download)

    A new press release from the Wisconsin Policy Research Institute propaganda mill trumpets “WISCONSIN RESIDENTS OVERWHELMINGLY OPPOSE RAISING TAXES ON BUSINESSES.”  Further down is the actual wording of the question asked of 600 Wisconsin residents: “Business profits are down throughout Wisconsin and many businesses are reducing their workforce. In this environment should state lawmakers increase the tax on businesses?”  This is what is known as a push poll, a “poll” where selected information is provided in order to shape the responses.  People who conduct push polls are not doing research, they are seeking to influence opinion.  People who conduct push polls should be shunned, not trusted.

    Imagine how different the results would have been if instead of the dubious and vague claims about profits and layoffs (unemployment has been steady in our state) the respondents had been told about a 2006 Associated Press study that found “Wisconsin companies saw their profits grow more than twice as fast as their state and local tax bills over a two-decade period.

    Instead of playing games with push polls, anyone who is serious about public policy in our state should be spending some time with a new report from the Wisconsin Council on Children and Families and the Institute for Wisconson’s Future entitled Catalog of Tax Reform Options for Wisconsin.  It is clear that there are many ways we can improve our tax policies and generate the revenues needed to fund education and other things the way we should.

    Thomas J. Mertz

    Leave a comment

    Filed under "education finance", Budget, education, finance, Gimme Some Truth, Local News, School Finance

    Quote of the Day – Priorities

    l_image101688cd0b59388fa7c1672e286d

    If one accepts the reasonable principle of supporting the new president whenever he makes policy from the left or addresses basic social needs, shouldn’t progressives be cheering the White House as it rolls out the dozers, Cats and big cranes? Aren’t high-speed mass transit and clean energy the kind of noble priorities that best reconcile big-bang stimulus with long-term public value?

    The answer is: no, not at this stage of our national emergency. I’m not an infrastructure-crisis denialist, but first things first. We are now at a crash site, and our priority should be to save the victims, not change the tires or repair the fender, much less build a new car. In the triage situation that now confronts the president-elect, keeping local schools and hospitals open should be the first concern, rebuilding bridges and expanding ports would come next, and rescuing bank shareholders at the very end of the line.

    Inexorably, the budgets of schools, cities and states are sinking into insolvency on a scale comparable to the early 1930s. The public-sector fiscal crisis — a vicious chain reaction of falling property values, incomes and sales — has been magnified by the unexpectedly large exposure of local governments and transit agencies to the Wall Street meltdown via complex capital lease-back arrangements. Meanwhile on the demand side, the need for public services explodes as even prudent burghers face foreclosure, not to speak of the loss of pensions and medical coverage. Although the public mega-deficits of California and New York may dominate headlines, the essence of the crisis — from the suburbs of Anchorage to the neighborhoods of West Philly — is its potential universality.

    Mike Davis, ” Why Obama’s Futurama Can Wait: Schools and Hospitals Should Come First in Any Stimulus Package.”

    Thomas J. Mertz

    Leave a comment

    Filed under "education finance", Best Practices, Budget, education, finance, National News, School Finance, Uncategorized

    Victory – Move on Up

    Just move on up
    and keep on wishing
    Remember your dreams
    are your only schemes
    So keep on pushing
    Take nothing less –
    Never second best
    And do not obey –
    you must have your say
    You can past the test

    Curtis Mayfield, “Move on Up.”

    The Madison school referendum, the Wisconsin Assembly, of course the Presidency and more — victories worth celebrating and building on.

    As Curtis says, “keep on pushing.”  This is just the start.  We need to stay involved and active to in order to move on up.

    Thomas J. Mertz

    2 Comments

    Filed under Accountability, Best Practices, Elections, Local News, National News, Referenda, referendum, Take Action

    Thank You Madison

    hands

    Robert Godfrey

    1 Comment

    Filed under AMPS, Elections, Local News, Referenda, School Finance