Observations, Endorsements


There has been much talk on the campaign trail about the need for a “cost benefit” analysis and the lack of forward planning. I find it disturbing that some of our candidates seem unaware of the 2002 Functional Analysis that MMSD commissioned from Virchow, Krause & Company, LLP. At that time, the district realized that the flawed state finance system would force cuts in the years ahead and wanted to be prepared. Because we have the analysis, we are prepared (nearly as well) as we can be for the challenges of the yearly budgeting.

I’m glad that this was commissioned and we have it to use. However, we all need to be careful and understand that all educational research and data is contingent, contextual and only provides guidance for decision-making. The factors that make a student achieve or fail are so complex and interactive that attributing causality is at best a matter of likelihood, not certainty. Some of the most important things, like the smile on a teacher’s face, defy quantification. Additionally, all the measures we use are to one degree or another subjective and flawed (see Fair Test for one set of examples). It isn’t science and applying the positivism of science and related reliance on “expertise” to education can be dangerous.

I value data and research as tools to inform educational policy, but I know that human judgment is the final and most important quality that we need on the Board of Education. This is one reason why I am supporting Beth Moss, Marjorie Passman and Johnny Winston Jr. in the April 3d Election. They are knowledgeable about our district and community, open to using data and research and have displayed the kind of judgement we need to keep our schools strong and getting stronger.

Thomas J. Mertz


Filed under AMPS, Best Practices, Budget, Elections, Local News

2 responses to “Observations, Endorsements

  1. Ed Blume

    The three candidates you mention will conduct business as usual in the MMSD, including ignoring the Virchow, Krause analysis and ignoring the impending disaster inherent in the flawed state finance system for the last four years.

    Maya Cole earned the endorsement of both the Cap Times and the State Journal.

    Out of all of the candidates she’s the most likely to move away from business as usual.

  2. What business? As long a Maya has your endorsement she is poor choice. Both Moss and Passman are solid choices. they are committed to lower class sizes and leaving benefits within the normal contractual process.

    Be honest Ed your business as unusual is they are not anti-MTI enough. It has nothing to do thinking outside the box, being status quot, or any other catchy phrase, it is that the believe there should be a democratic process in contractual disputes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s